As a sports rehabilitation specialist and strength coach who also reviews cold plunge products, I care less about hype and more about repeatable outcomes that reduce stress, support recovery, and keep athletes safe. One deceptively small choice—whether to keep your eyes closed or open during an ice bath—can meaningfully shape your stress response. The difference lives in how visual input interacts with the brain’s networks that regulate arousal, and how that interplay shows up in cortisol dynamics. This article unpacks what is known, what is plausible, and how to choose the right strategy for your context, with practical protocols and product setup tips that align with evidence on stress physiology, eye health, and behavior.
Why Cortisol Matters In Cold Exposure
Cortisol is a steroid hormone produced by the adrenal glands and coordinated by the brain’s hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis. It rises with perceived stress and helps mobilize energy, regulate blood pressure, and tune alertness; it is not the enemy, but it does become problematic when chronically elevated or poorly regulated. Cleveland Clinic emphasizes that cortisol supports healthy daily rhythms and that persistently high levels over weeks and months can drive inflammation and a range of mental and physical symptoms. Johns Hopkins Medicine and Mayo Clinic both highlight that deliberate relaxation practices and paced breathing can downshift arousal, improving sleep and stress regulation. In practical terms for cold exposure, the goal is not zero cortisol; the goal is a controlled stress dose with a quick, reliable recovery.
What Eyes Open vs Eyes Closed Does In The Brain
A resting‑state fMRI study in healthy adults examined brain activity during eyes-closed followed by eyes-open conditions, and collected salivary cortisol in a subset of participants. The authors reported that opening the eyes after a period of eyes closed produced a short-lived, synchronized rise in network activity across multiple brain systems. They also found that pre-scan salivary cortisol positively correlated with limbic connectivity under both eyes-closed and eyes-open conditions. The authors interpreted the abrupt move from a relaxed, eyes-closed state to eyes-open as potentially aversive or novel, which can momentarily upshift stress-related network engagement. This does not prove that opening the eyes always raises cortisol, but it does suggest that an eyes-closed baseline followed by an eyes-open transition can transiently amplify arousal in a way that overlaps with how the brain organizes stress responses. These findings live alongside clinical stress guidance from Cleveland Clinic, Johns Hopkins Medicine, and Mayo Clinic showing that breathing and relaxation reliably lower arousal, which is highly relevant to how you structure vision and attention during an ice bath.
Stress And The Eyes: What Your Visual System Feels Under Pressure
The American Academy of Ophthalmology notes that stress hormones such as adrenaline and cortisol are linked with pupil dilation, transient increases in intraocular pressure, and heightened light sensitivity. Clinical guidance from ophthalmology sources describes temporary blurring, twitching, dryness, and photophobia during periods of elevated stress. A study published on PubMed Central found that cortisol measured in human tears correlated positively with anxiety scores in students, suggesting that ocular surface sensations and stress are intertwined. Other eye-care sources emphasize that stress reduces blink rate during intense focus and can destabilize the tear film, compounding eye strain and dryness. Taken together, visual and ocular comfort are not trivial during a cold plunge. Bright light or glare, hypervigilant scanning, and the novelty of opening the eyes while bracing against cold can each raise perceived load and potentially nudge your stress response upward.
Translating The Science To The Ice: Why Eyes Closed Often Helps Early, And Eyes Open Still Matters
The brain imaging research indicates that transitions from eyes closed to eyes open can act like a small jolt of novelty. In practice, that means you can use eyes-closed immersion as a tool to reduce sensory input at the exact moment when cold shock peaks. Combine this with slow, deliberate breathing to anchor the parasympathetic system. Cleveland Clinic advocates movement, sleep, time in nature, and mindfulness practices to help regulate cortisol; Johns Hopkins Medicine recommends planned relaxation and tracking stress ratings before and after practice to reinforce learning. Body & Mind Online describes several breathing drills, including the “physiological sigh,” with evidence summarized by Stanford-affiliated work, where two quick nasal inhales followed by a long exhale rapidly reduce stress. These elements mesh well with eyes‑closed immersion for the first phase.
Eyes open remains essential for safety and situational awareness. Opening the eyes helps you orient to your environment, confirm footing, and monitor time and posture. However, be aware that shifting from a calm eyes-closed state into eyes-open vigilance can feel like a brief mental upshift. Anticipating that moment and pairing it with longer exhales tends to blunt the spike for many athletes in my care. In short, eyes closed can buy you calm at entry; eyes open keeps you safe and honest about your position and form.
A Coach’s Protocol You Can Adapt
On the training floor and in clinic, I see the best results when athletes build a consistent sensory script. Before stepping in, dim visual clutter if you can, reduce glare, and establish a breathing rhythm. During the first phase of immersion, keep the eyes closed or softly unfocused and use longer exhales to ride out the cold shock. When you open the eyes to check time, form, or safety, expect a small uptick in alertness. Do not fight it; simply guide it back down with deliberate breathing or a brief physiological sigh. At exit, return to a calm stance, breathe slowly, and note your perceived stress and mood. Johns Hopkins Medicine suggests using a 0–10 scale for perceived stress before and after practice. Over repeated sessions, this becomes a reliable feedback loop; you learn what visual strategy gives you the most stable response.
Eye Comfort And Safety During Cold Plunges
Stress amplifies light sensitivity and can reduce blink rate, leading to dryness and eye fatigue, which several ophthalmology sources describe. If your setup reflects harsh light, consider shading the area or changing the angle to reduce glare so your eyes do not become an extra stress driver. The American Academy of Ophthalmology notes that recurring light sensitivity should be discussed with an eye doctor, and that stress can transiently raise intraocular pressure. If you have glaucoma or significant ocular disease, speak with your ophthalmologist about how to manage stress, cold exposure, and visual load together. For most healthy athletes, keeping the head and face above water, reducing glare, and avoiding prolonged fixed staring helps comfort without compromising safety.
Comparing Eyes Closed And Eyes Open During Ice Baths
Visual state |
Sensory load and arousal |
Practical cortisol implication |
When I favor it |
Notes and safety |
Source anchor |
Eyes closed |
Lower visual input; reduced novelty and scanning; easier to pair with relaxation breathing |
May reduce perceived arousal during the initial cold shock |
Early immersion or recovery-focused sessions |
Maintain physical safety with stable footing and supervision; orient before closing eyes |
Frontiers in Psychology; Cleveland Clinic; Johns Hopkins Medicine |
Eyes open |
Higher visual input; orientation and situational awareness; potential brief arousal uptick after eyes-closed baseline |
May transiently increase alertness when switching from eyes closed |
Entry/exit, time checks, and any moment requiring postural correction |
Use soft gaze and longer exhales to blunt the spike; minimize glare when possible |
Frontiers in Psychology; Mayo Clinic; American Academy of Ophthalmology |
This table frames directionally plausible responses without claiming that eyes open or eyes closed universally raises or lowers cortisol in every person and session. It also aligns with the brain imaging evidence about eyes-closed to eyes-open transitions and established stress-reduction guidance from clinical sources.
How To Breathe When Vision Changes Your Stress
The most reliable way to manage the small arousal waves that accompany visual state changes is to anchor exhalation. Clinicians at Cleveland Clinic and Mayo Clinic consistently recommend breath-centered relaxation to lower arousal. Body & Mind Online outlines drills such as box breathing, extended exhalation patterns like 4‑7‑8, and the physiological sigh. In cold water, extended exhales are practical because they are simple and portable; you can do them with your eyes closed to ride down the initial spike, and again with your eyes open after a time check or repositioning. Johns Hopkins Medicine recommends practicing relaxation daily and using before-and-after stress ratings to reinforce the skill; that approach translates well to cold plunges, where consistency is the real lever.
A Note On Measuring Cortisol
If you are curious about biomarkers, the brain imaging study used salivary cortisol, and a separate PubMed Central study measured cortisol in human tears while examining anxiety and ocular surface symptoms. Consumer at‑home cortisol tests are available, as noted in educational materials from Mutual of Omaha, but interpretation can be tricky. Cortisol varies by time of day, context, and individual factors, so numbers without a plan rarely change behavior. A practical compromise is to pair subjective 0–10 stress ratings and mood logs with consistent sessions and simple protocols; if you still want to test, coordinate with a clinician so you can make sense of the data. The behavior is the intervention, and the numbers should serve the behavior.
Pros And Cons In Plain Language
Eyes closed often makes the initial immersion more tolerable by dampening novelty and reducing visual load. It helps you lock into longer exhales and can make the whole experience feel more controlled. The downside is reduced awareness; you must ensure stable footing, safe entry and exit, and appropriate supervision. Eyes open gives you awareness and accountability to posture, time, and safety. The tradeoff is that visual input can momentarily lift arousal, especially when you switch from a relaxed eyes-closed state. Expect that and meet it with exhale‑biased breathing rather than assuming something is wrong.
Product Setup And Buying Considerations To Support A Calmer, Safer Plunge
The way your cold plunge is set up has a real influence on perceived stress. Place the unit where glare is minimal or add shade so the visual environment is not another stressor. Choose a location with clear lines of sight for supervision and safe entry. Favor tubs or tanks that provide stable stepping and a secure stance so you can safely keep your eyes lightly closed during the first moments if that helps you. A quiet operating environment reduces auditory load while you settle your breath. Keep a simple, visible timer in your line of sight so that when you do open your eyes, you can orient quickly and return to longer exhales. If you train at night, use softer, indirect lighting to reduce photic stress. These are product-agnostic choices that make your session more repeatable without adding complexity.
Special Populations And Eye Health
The American Academy of Ophthalmology advises that stress can transiently raise intraocular pressure and that recurring light sensitivity should be evaluated. If you have glaucoma, significant dry eye disease, or thyroid-related eye conditions, consult your ophthalmologist about visual load, stress, and cold exposure together. Research published on PubMed Central links anxiety with ocular surface symptoms and cortisol in tears; if your eyes tend to be irritable under stress, prioritize glare reduction, blink naturally, and keep the head above water to avoid compounding discomfort. None of these considerations rule out cold exposure, but they do place a premium on environment, supervision, and pacing.
Building A Repeatable Session: Coach’s Template
A repeatable session begins before you touch the water. Take a few slow breaths to establish rhythm and decide your initial visual strategy. If you plan to start with eyes closed, orient your stance first, then soften the gaze or close your eyes as you begin immersion. Expect the cold shock to crest quickly. Lengthen your exhale and allow your shoulders to settle. When you open your eyes to check time or position, accept the brief uptick in alertness and ride it back down with a longer exhale or a single physiological sigh. On exit, keep your breathing unforced, rate your perceived stress and mood, and make a short note about what worked. That is how you learn your individual response pattern rather than chasing someone else’s routine.
Evidence Snapshot And Practical Implications
Topic |
Key finding |
Practical implication for ice baths |
Source |
Eyes-closed to eyes-open transitions |
Opening the eyes after eyes-closed rest produced short-lived network-wide activity increases; pre-scan salivary cortisol correlated with limbic connectivity |
Expect a momentary alertness bump when you shift from eyes closed to eyes open; meet it with longer exhales |
Frontiers in Psychology |
Cortisol and the eye surface |
Cortisol measured in human tears correlated with higher anxiety scores; anxiety and ocular symptoms tracked together |
If stress irritates your eyes, manage glare, blink naturally, and keep the head above water to reduce ocular load |
PubMed Central |
Stress and eye symptoms |
Stress hormones can dilate pupils, increase light sensitivity, and transiently raise intraocular pressure; stress-related dryness and twitching are common |
Reduce visual strain with softer light, avoid harsh glare, and use breath control to lower arousal |
American Academy of Ophthalmology; Clinical London |
Stress reduction behaviors |
Consistent breathing, mindfulness, sleep hygiene, and nature exposure help regulate cortisol and improve recovery |
Pair eyes-closed immersion with exhale‑biased breathing; practice relaxation daily for carryover |
Cleveland Clinic; Johns Hopkins Medicine; Mayo Clinic |
Breathing techniques |
Slow, deliberate breathing strategies, including physiological sighs and extended exhales, reduce stress rapidly |
Use longer exhales during cold shock and again after eyes-open time checks |
Body & Mind Online; Stanford‑affiliated summaries cited therein |
Takeaway
Eyes closed and eyes open are not aesthetic choices in an ice bath; they are tools that shift sensory load and shape your stress response. Evidence suggests that transitions from eyes closed to eyes open can briefly raise arousal, and that exhale‑biased breathing reliably counterbalances that effect. Use eyes closed to tame the initial cold shock when safe to do so, then use eyes open for orientation and accountability, accepting a brief uptick in alertness and guiding it down with your breath. Reduce glare, simplify your environment, and build a consistent script. Recovery is not about fighting your physiology; it is about giving it the right inputs, at the right moments, every time.
FAQ
Does closing my eyes during an ice bath lower cortisol?
Closing your eyes reduces visual input and can make the initial cold shock feel less novel and less intense. Brain imaging research shows that transitions from eyes closed to eyes open can transiently amplify arousal, and clinical guidance from Cleveland Clinic and Mayo Clinic supports using breath-centered relaxation to lower stress. While no study here directly compares cortisol during eyes-closed versus eyes-open ice baths, pairing eyes closed with longer exhales is a sensible way to reduce perceived arousal during entry.
Why do I feel a sudden jolt when I open my eyes in the cold?
Research published in Frontiers in Psychology found that opening the eyes after eyes-closed rest produced short-lived increases in activity across brain networks associated with attention and salience. In practice, that feels like a brief alertness bump. It is not a problem; anticipate it, then guide your system back down with a long exhale or a physiological sigh.
Are there eye-related risks with stress during cold exposure?
Ophthalmology guidance notes that stress hormones can dilate pupils, raise light sensitivity, and transiently increase intraocular pressure, while dryness and twitching can also appear. If you notice recurring light sensitivity or eye discomfort, reduce glare in your setup, blink naturally, and keep the head above water. The American Academy of Ophthalmology recommends seeking care for persistent or severe symptoms.
How should I breathe to manage the stress waves?
Extend your exhale. Cleveland Clinic, Johns Hopkins Medicine, and Mayo Clinic all emphasize that slow breathing and relaxation lower arousal. Body & Mind Online outlines techniques such as the physiological sigh, which can rapidly reduce stress. Use longer exhales during immersion, and again after you open your eyes to check time or posture.
Should I measure cortisol to optimize my protocol?
You can, but it is not necessary for most athletes. The fMRI study used salivary cortisol; a separate PubMed Central study measured tear cortisol as a stress biomarker in students. Educational materials from Mutual of Omaha note that at‑home cortisol tests exist, but interpretation is context-dependent. For practical training, simple 0–10 stress and mood ratings before and after sessions, as recommended by Johns Hopkins Medicine, often provide clearer guidance for behavior change.
How do I set up my cold plunge to keep stress lower without compromising safety?
Choose a placement that minimizes glare, set soft lighting if you train at night, and ensure stable entry and exit. Keep a simple timer in your line of sight so that when you open your eyes, you can orient quickly. Start with eyes closed only once you have stable footing and supervision, then open your eyes for checks and adjustments, meeting any alertness bump with longer exhales.
References
Cleveland Clinic; Johns Hopkins Medicine; Mayo Clinic; American Academy of Ophthalmology; Frontiers in Psychology; PubMed Central; Body & Mind Online; Clinical London; Space Coast Ophthalmology; Mutual of Omaha
- https://www.colorado.edu/law/25-quick-ways-reduce-stress
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451453/
- https://healthcare.utah.edu/healthfeed/2024/06/hormones-and-eye-health-what-women-need-know
- https://health.clevelandclinic.org/how-to-reduce-cortisol-and-turn-down-the-dial-on-stress
- https://www.aao.org/eye-health/tips-prevention/anxiety-stress-dry-eye-glaucoma-iop
- https://www.gundersenhealth.org/health-wellness/mental-health-relationships/4-7-8-breathing-technique
- https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/wellness-and-prevention/sleepless-nights-try-stress-relief-techniques
- https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1411835/full
- https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/stress-management/in-depth/relaxation-technique/art-20045368
- https://www.emvc.net/what-is-the-impact-of-hormones-on-dry-eyes
